Holding Attorneys Accountable for Unauthorized Settlements
In New York, the client — not the lawyer — has the final say on whether to accept or reject a settlement. When an attorney agrees to a settlement without the client’s knowledge or approval, it is a serious breach of trust and may amount to legal malpractice.
At The C. Paul Law Firm P.C., we represent clients across [City] and New York whose attorneys settled cases without their consent. If your lawyer gave away your rights or financial recovery without your authorization, we can help you hold them accountable.
Call today for a free consultation: (212) 551-PAUL
What is Settlement Without Consent?
Settlement is a client decision. Lawyers may advise, but they cannot accept or reject an offer without the client’s approval. Doing so violates the attorney’s fiduciary duty and may cause significant financial loss.
Common Scenarios of Unauthorized Settlements
| Misconduct | Example | Legal Impact |
| Undervalued Settlement | Lawyer accepts far less than case is worth without client approval | Client loses rightful compensation |
| Hidden Agreement | Attorney finalizes settlement behind client’s back | Breach of fiduciary duty |
| Pressure from Opposing Counsel | Lawyer agrees quickly to “clear the case” | Client’s rights compromised |
| Failure to Inform | Lawyer never communicates the offer to client | Deprives client of decision-making |
| Financial Self-Interest | Lawyer pushes settlement to collect fees faster | Conflict of interest, malpractice |
Proving Legal Malpractice in Unauthorized Settlements
To succeed in a claim, clients generally must prove:
- Attorney-Client Relationship – A formal relationship existed.
- Breach of Duty – The lawyer settled without consent.
- Causation – The unauthorized settlement harmed the client.
- Damages – The client lost money, rights, or both.
Compensation for Victims of Unauthorized Settlements
If your lawyer settled your case without consent, you may be entitled to recover:
- Difference between fair value of the case and the unauthorized settlement
- Legal fees wasted on negligent representation
- Financial losses tied to waived claims
- Emotional distress caused by betrayal of trust
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a lawyer legally settle my case without asking me?
No. Settlement decisions belong exclusively to the client.
What if my lawyer pressured me into a settlement?
If you were misled, coerced, or misinformed, you may have a malpractice claim.
What if I never knew about a settlement until it was too late?
Failing to disclose settlement offers is a breach of fiduciary duty and malpractice.
How long do I have to file a malpractice claim in New York?
Generally 3 years from when the malpractice occurred or was discovered.
Serving [City] and the Greater New York Area
We represent malpractice victims in [City], Manhattan, Queens, Brooklyn, the Bronx, and across New York whose lawyers settled cases without consent.